Trisha Yearwood performs "Georgia Rain" during 2005 CMT Music Awards - Show at Gaylord Entertainment Center in Nashville, Tennessee, United States.
J.Sciulli/WireImage for CMT: Country Music Television

12 Songs that Made Trisha Yearwood a Country Music Legend

Trisha Yearwood songs point back to a time when talented women got a fair shake in Nashville, allowing a wide range of listeners to discover these and other great songs.

Whether solo or with future husband Garth Brooks as her duet partner, Yearwood's best songs represent a time when mainstream county struck a healthy balance between honoring traditional sounds and chasing pop acceptance.

Here's our playlist of the 12 greatest hits by a Grand Ole Opry member and multi-time CMA, ACM and Grammy award winner.

12. "Believe Me Baby (I Lied)" (Everybody Knows, 1996)

Trisha Yearwood during "Stuart Little" Los Angeles Premiere at Mann Village Theatre in Westwood, California, United States.


The narrator in the second single from Everybody Knows admits they were playing it cool when acting like they weren't giddy about a potential relationship with whoever's on the other end of the phone. The admission of "wounded pride" became the fourth of five Yearwood singles to top the Billboard Hot Country Songs chart.

Listen here.

11. "Thinkin' About You," (Thinkin' About You, 1995)

Trisha Yearwood performs at Shoreline Amphitheatre on September 24, 1994 in Mountain View, California.

Tim Mosenfelder/Getty Images

Yearwood sings of wistful daydreaming about a special someone on what became the third No. 1. She sounds great, as usual, so there's something else setting this one apart: slide guitar accompaniment by fellow country star Lee Roy Parnell.

Listen here.

10. "How Do I Live" ((Songbook) A Collection of Hits, 1997)

Photo of Trisha YEARWOOD; Trisha Yearwood performing on stage circa 1997

David Redfern/Redferns

A rundown of the best Yearwood songs would be incomplete without this one, even if Leann Rimes' stellar rendition of a Diane Warren original might be better-known now. This recording that made it in the film Con Air and earned Yearwood a Grammy Award will always represent a particular moment in pop culture history.

9. "Georgia Rain" (Jasper County, 2005)

Trisha Yearwood during 40th Annual Academy of Country Music Awards - Show at Mandalay Bay Resort and Casino Events Center in Las Vegas, Nevada, United States.

M. Caulfield/WireImage for Bragman Nyman Cafarelli

The main selling point of Yearwood's 2005 comeback album Jasper County remains this sentimental song that references the singer's home state. It's a five minute-plus story-song that's a near-perfect showcase of Yearwood's mighty alto vocals.

Listen here.

8. "That's What I Like About You" (Trisha Yearwood, 1991)

Trisha Yearwood live circa 1992

William Campbell/Sygma via Getty Images

Like Sara Evans and other country singer peers, Yearwood came out the gate with traditional-sounding country songs. Take for instance this 1991 cut that's a honky-tonk throwback. Indeed, the co-write by underrated solo artist Kevin Welch is as rollicking as anything by Alan Jackson or anyone else in Nashville.

Listen here.

7. "In Another's Eyes" (Feat. Garth Brooks ((Songbook) A Collection of Hits, 1997)

Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood during 33rd Annual Academy of Country Music Awards at Universal Ampitheater in Universal City, California, United States.

Ron Galella, Ltd./Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

This Yearwood and Brooks duet is good enough to warrant consideration for his and her best songs lists. It left enough of an imprint on country music that it would've linked them together forever without their future marriage. Other duets of note range from Yearwood's second single ever, 1991's "Like We Never Had a Broken Heart," to the title track of Yearwood's 1998 studio album Where Your Road Leads.

Listen here.

6. "Wrong Side of Memphis" (Hearts in Armor, 1992)

Trisha Yearwood during 19th Annual American Music Awards at Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles, California, United States.

Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

Yearwood's offering that best mirrored some of her peers' bluesy, rocking vibe also features classic country instrumentation, accentuating a story-song with a strong sense of place. This was the first single on her second album, Hearts in Armor.

Listen here.

5. "Walkaway Joe" (With Don Henley) (Hearts in Armor, 1992)

Trisha Yearwood red carpet photo from 1992

Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

One of the saddest songs of its time, "Walkaway Joe" teams Yearwood with the Eagles' Don Henley for a tale of hard living and broken hearts. Bonus points for a music video that stars a then-unknown Matthew McConaughey.

Listen here.

4. "The Song Remembers When" (The Song Remembers When, 1993)

Singer Trisha Yearwood and singer Kathy Mattea attend the 28th Annual Academy of Country Music Awards on May 11, 1993 at Universal Amphitheatre in Universal City, California.

Ron Galella, Ltd./Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

This weepy ballad —the kind that's made Reba McEntire millions— remains one of the best examples of Yearwood's vast talent as a soulful vocalist and emotive song interpreter. The song was written by Hugh Prestwood and originally recorded to Kathy Mattea, though it never made it onto one of her albums.

Listen here.

3. "A Perfect Love" ((Songbook) A Collection of Hits, 1997)


David Redfern/Redferns

High-energy '90s country, custom made to match the scope of a stadium show, suited Yearwood's mighty voice, as heard on this classic single about what a powerful thing love is and what a joy it is find it. It's one of several bonus tracks from a greatest hits compilation that made it onto our list.

Listen here.

2. "XXX's and OOO's (An American Girl)" (Thinkin' About You, 1995)

Trisha Yearwood during The 37th Annual GRAMMY Awards at Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles, California, United States.

Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

Often, a great country song's narrator tells a first-person story that's relatable to people from all walks of life. Yearwood really does sing for the small-town, all-American youngster on this co-write by the great Alice Randall and Matraca Berg. It's the lead single from platinum disc Thinkin' About You.

Listen here.

1. "She's In Love With The Boy" (Trisha Yearwood, 1991)

Trisha Yearwood during 27th Annual Academy of Country Music Awards at Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles, California, United States.

Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

As usual, it's hard to argue against the most obvious song being an artist's best. Yearwood's debut single still gets stuck in the heads of anyone who runs across it on a streaming playing— or, in true '90s fashion, gives her self-titled debut album a spin.

Listen here.

This story was first published in 2018.

READ MORE: 12 Country Stunners by '90s Icon Lorrie Morgan