The Best Halloween Cookie Cutters to Make Classic Sugar Cookies Creepy & Cute

Editor's Note: Products featured on Wide Open Eats are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

My heart is broken every time I go to H-E-B and notice that they're out of Pillsbury Halloween cookies. Please, I just want some sugar cookies with ghosts and pumpkins on them! I guess I'll have to whip up some homemade Halloween sugar cookies with these Halloween cookie cutters in case this happens again.

We rounded up Halloween cookie cutters that feature all of our favorite creepy creatures. Ghosts, skulls, bats, and more. I can't wait to put these to use! Now, all I need is the Pillsbury sugar cookie recipe.

Cookie Cutters for Spooky Season

1. Ann Clark Cookie Cutters Pumpkin Cookie Cutter, 4"

Keep it simple with a pumpkin cookie cutter! These will come in handy for a Halloween party or just general fall-themed cookies.

It's a #1 Amazon bestseller.

2. Ghost Cookie Cutter 4 in

Of course, we had to include ghosts.

3. 4.3 inch Skull Cookie Cutter - Stainless Steel

If you dabble in cake decorating, try to take your cookie decorating skills to the next level by creating Day of the Dead sugar skull cookies.

4. LILIAO Witch Hat Cookie Cutter for Halloween

Witch's hat cookies are going to be a hit for Hocus Pocus movie night.

5. Candy Corn Cookie Cutter, 3.75"

I'm really bad about eating cookie dough, but I'll be sure to save it for the oven, thanks to these adorable cookie cutters! This is so cute.

6. 12 Piece Set

Can't decide which one you want? Grab this 12-pack Halloween cookie cutter set. You can make black cats, bat, tombstone cookies, and more.

7. Wilton Halloween Metal Cookie Cutter Set, 18-Piece

Grab this 18-pack for the ultimate spooky cookie batch. (I used these mini cookie cutters to add designs to my jack-o-lantern.)

8. Ann Clark Cookie Cutters Spider Web Cookie Cutter

This baking tool allows you to cut out spider web cookies! How neat!

9. Haunted House 102 Cookie Cutter Set!

These haunted house cookie cutters are a must if you're ready to decorate! Spice things up with various icings.

10. Tombstone Cookie Cutter - Stainless Steel

Tombstone cookie cutters are perfect for watching classic mummy movies.

For more Halloween cookie cutters sets, biscuit cutters, and rolling pins, visit Amazon.

This post was originally published on September 3, 2021.