A Florida man allegedly did something extreme and quite diabolical to get back at a person whom he believes was connected with his and his now ex-wife's marital split. Per The New York Post, Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., who is 68, slapped a bunch of peanut butter inside a greeting card and sent it to a woman with an intense allergy to the spread. She received the potentially dangerous letter on August 14, 2025. After getting it, the woman scurried into her home to scrub every trace of the stuff off herself. According to the outlet, she felt a "tingling" sensation, along with having hives on her arms for hours.
Videos by Wide Open Country
Cancellare allegedly did that to get back at her for supposedly playing a role in his split from his now ex-wife. The couple and this woman were all well-acquainted for many years. She thought that Joseph Cancellare would have definitely known about her allergy to peanuts.
He was reportedly arrested on November 13 for the peculiar alleged crime. Cancellare has been been "charged with culpable negligence exposing another person to harm and aggravated battery with a deadly weapon," per the outlet.
Peanut Allergies Are Potentially Very Serious
Being exposed to or especially ingesting peanut butter, for those with allergies to the substance, can be extremely problematic. According to the Mayo Clinic, some people can get a potentially life-threatening reaction to peanuts or products that contain them. That reaction is called anaphylaxis
Symptoms of this serious condition include elevated pulse rate, airways constricting, quickly-dropping blood pressure, and difficulty breathing. The Mayo Clinic states, "The most common cause of peanut allergy is eating peanuts or foods that contain peanuts."
The woman in question was described by police as being "deathly allergic," per NBC6 South Florida. She can experience a reaction to peanuts through inhalation, handling, or eating them.
Cancellare Allegedly Went to Great Lengths To Conceal Who He Was When Buying the Stamps He Used
Per NBC6, he allegedly tried really hard to disguise his identity when he bought the stamps he used on the letter. Authorities noted that "...Joseph drove to a USPS store in a different city than where he lived." Additionally, Cancellare allegedly kept his sunglasses on while completing the transaction. He also reportedly put a fake return address and name on the envelope. Nevertheless, Cancellare's alleged plot to harm this woman was discovered just the same.
